Reviewer Rating Profile

Commander Phantom (#6199)

Reviewer Average Rating: 3.7
Number of Battle Reviews: 11
5
Reviewed: 2003-07-05
Reviewed: 2003-07-05
Great job Frodo!
5
Reviewed: 2003-01-31
Reviewed: 2003-01-31
Great job Tiss!!
5
Reviewed: 2003-01-05
Nice battle. I like the personnal touch in the fourth mission.
5
Reviewed: 2002-09-15
Reviewed: 2002-09-15
Great story line. Very challenging. Great job, Tiss.
5
Reviewed: 2002-09-09
Great battle. I think I'll fly it again for the fun of it. Great job Mike.
4
Reviewed: 2002-05-26
Reviewed: 2002-05-26
One of the best missions I've flown so far. Great work!
4
Reviewed: 2002-05-06
The missions were great, although, the goals could have been a little more clearer on what was to be accomplished. Stll, alot of thought had gone into this creation. Good job!
5
Reviewed: 2002-04-30
Reviewed: 2002-04-30
Being the first mission I've flown, this beats any mission that is programmed in the XvT game. Keep up the gos work!
2
Reviewed: 2002-01-20
Reviewed: 2002-01-20
Not a bad battle, but it seems like every mission you fight the same 4 groups of Tie Defenders. It wouldn't be that bad except for the lack of variety in enemy craft.
1
Reviewed: 2001-05-28
Reviewed: 2001-05-28
The only reason I am even giving this battle a 1 is that the creator found an original idea to the battles of repeating them over and over from different points of view. Other than that, there were about 4 different battles throughout the entire thing. There were 2 patches, but they were used only once each. Overall I think this was a terrible battle and don't understand how it was approved. Don't fly this battle!
0
Reviewed: 2001-02-21
Reviewed: 2001-02-21
Pretty easy to complete, but the amount of starfighters are ridiculous. It was fun for about the first minute and then it just got monotonous with wave after wave of starfighters. There is nothing to do but kill and the storyline is pretty unconvincing.

Showing all 11 records