Nice battle, one slight problem with the .lst file though. It seems Mission 1 dupplicates. No big deal. ;)

Plot needs an overhaul. As for missions, well 3 and 4 are some of the worst I've ever seen. Like disabling T/As with a 4 GUNs, and without any casualties on your side...that's stratching it a bit far.

One of the worst battle ever, and it includes the worst mission ever (Mission 4). You've got to do everything with almost nothing. Forget about your wingmen, they're just a bit more intelligent than an auto-pilot. This battle should've never been approved and needs a major overhaul... Besides, giving your own battle a rating of 4 to get a higher overall rating ain't a good idea...

This is a strange battle. Fairly easy, but very interesting...When's the next wargame ? ;)

Way too easy. You might want to check the enemy fighters AI. The battle also need a solid plot, more than a couple of sentences patched together.

Nice battle. I enjoyed it...even if it involves flying X-Wings. ;)

Overall, nice battle. Not too hard, not too easy. You gotta keep an eye on the battlefield for incoming enemy ships, which is much better than some turkey shooting missions out there.

Poor briefings, poor missions. Too much waiting.

This is original, to say the least. Missions are well constructed and sound files are original too. However, I hated the plotline. I prefer more serious encounters. I know how hard it is to design a battle, so I don't think I'm too tough by giving it a 3.