Reviewer Rating Profile
Lieutenant Colonel Gen Es'mith (#589)
Reviewer Average Rating: 3.4Number of Battle Reviews: 69
2
Reviewed: 2001-04-23
Reviewed: 2001-04-23
Although it has a wonderful plot and breifing, I found it once again an exercise in frustration as ONE pilot has to vaingloriously solve all the problems of a squadron or more.
5
Reviewed: 2001-04-23
Reviewed: 2001-04-23
Suprisingly flawless cooperation from your wingmen, and Gunboats that complete their mission. An excellently well written mission.
5
Reviewed: 2001-01-01
Reviewed: 2001-01-01
I like this FREE-TIE. Well put together with a nice story line :-)
5
Reviewed: 2000-06-15
Reviewed: 2000-06-15
Probably the single best Free Mission I have flown. Taking out A-Wings with a TIE Fighter while they are doing their job. It was a joy!!!
4
3
Reviewed: 2000-06-07
Reviewed: 2000-06-07
A lot of work for a lone T/A having to help out his squadron mates. But achievable, non the less. I fly TIE95.
4
Reviewed: 2000-06-07
Reviewed: 2000-06-07
A good mission where wingmen and supporting aircraft actually do their jobs while you attend to business. I fly TIE95.
2
Reviewed: 2000-06-07
Reviewed: 2000-06-07
A flyable mission, but rather a dissappointment in that there is not really much to do. I fly TIE95
5
Reviewed: 2000-06-07
Reviewed: 2000-06-07
A well balanced and interesting mission. I had no problems with briefings or anything else. I fly TIE95.
5
Reviewed: 2000-03-10
Reviewed: 2000-03-10
A high rating, why? There was a marked difference between difficulty levels. I have three other family members in the TIE Corps. I flew it on hard and had some difficulty, my wife flew it on medium and it went well. My sons flew on easy and succeeded brialliantly in the (for a 9 and 7 year old) difficult task of putting warheads on target. Good Job!!!
2
Reviewed: 2000-02-24
Reviewed: 2000-02-24
Nothing is better than to be the center of attention of A-Wings in a TIE Bomber. Killer though is the "Friendly" Fire in three separate missions.
2
Reviewed: 2000-02-23
Reviewed: 2000-02-23
Missions are uninspired if viewed in terms of being bounty hunters. Could be a typical TC battle otherwise. Low rating due to bug in mission 4.
4
Reviewed: 2000-02-08
Reviewed: 2000-02-08
I have to give this a 4, not so much for flying and combat skills needed by the player, but because the Admiral put much effort into maps, briefings and even slipped in a working patch for you. I appreciate the work he put into it...although the A-Wing Black (on hard) can be quite irritating....... I flew it with TIE95.
3
Reviewed: 2000-02-07
Reviewed: 2000-02-07
Overall, a bit easy to fly, but a serious handicap exists without proper pre and post mission briefings as well as a briefing map for all of the missions
5
Reviewed: 2000-01-30
Reviewed: 2000-01-30
This is my favorite kind of mission: Alot of rebels to kill and no other Imperials to steal your kills :) This is really a great mission.
2
Reviewed: 2000-01-25
Reviewed: 2000-01-25
In several of the missions, friendly craft continue to attack mission critical craft, even after being disabled and captured.
3
Reviewed: 1999-12-18
Reviewed: 1999-12-18
This battle is about average, but it does have a good plotline, and good mission design. Overall, I enjoyed flying it.
4
Reviewed: 1999-11-17
Reviewed: 1999-11-17
I liked the military style tactical/strategic goals of this battle.
4
Reviewed: 1999-10-18
Reviewed: 1999-10-18
Enjoyable battle overall. The Mission 2, convoy escort duty was not challenging enough for a competent missile boat jockey. Had a missed goal on Mission 3 of not keeping one x-wing alive, although I did. The destruction of the x-wing squadron in Mission 5 might seemed out of place or anti-climactic, as the Battle's goals had already been achieved. But I did enjoy it.