Nothing ground-breaking, but everything works and it's reasonably challenging depending on how you want to play it.

Well put together battle, with plenty of enjoyable scraps with starfighters and capships. Good stuff!

Well made and bug free. Recommended.

Awful, awful battle. Fly for FCHG points, nothing more. The last mission is particularly frustrating, as you're vastly out-numbered while your ISD sits in another region doing absolutely nothing.

Not nearly as good as some of the other reviews suggest. The plot is rather silly (especially when blowing up fellow DB ships, only for them to reappear in the next mission), and the custom craft are really only a small redeeming feature. The third mission is way too hectic, with Frigates flying around all over the place shooting at each other; it's very hard to work out which ones you're supposed to kill in the heat of battle. In the last mission you fly an unshielded T/I, which is supposed to be challenging of course, but it just gets frustrating when your wingmen fly into you and destroy your ship. It would help if the orders for the wingmen were a little more sophisticated, so they don't all go after the same enemy fighter (and thus endangering you).

Funny plot, I just wish everything got started sooner. Perhaps a trigger should have been placed in the mission, so you can force the Rebels to arrive earlier than 6 minutes. Other than that I think it makes a nice competition mission because it's short and sweet :)

To be honest the plot is quite silly and far-fetched, with little explanation of what's really going on. The enemy craft are also pretty easy to kill. Perfectly playable, just not as much fun as you'd expect.

Whilst innovative, this is a horrible, horrible battle. Far too frustrating for my liking; I'd prefer to see this kind of innovation in a proper battle scenario rather than a set of training missions, typically involving mines and flying an unshielded TIE (why? what is the obsession, people?!). I know some people must love the way the battle-maker has achieved some of the things in this battle, but that alone doesn't make it good or (more importantly) fun.

Lots of fun, but at times the large numbers of low-skilled AI enemy fighters gets a little repetitive. Also, the positioning of craft in each mission is very two-dimensional. On the whole, it's not too bad a battle, but it's nothing amazing, either.

Some of the missions took a little *too* long, but overall it was a reasonable battle. It would have been nice if my command ship had used its lasers once in a while.

This battle has little depth in plot, but it's good fun to fly! If you like lots of dogfighting and easy capital ship kills - enjoy! I did have a little problem in the last mission where blowing up the Gun Platforms killed some of my squadron, but oh well, they died for a good cause :P

Starts off quite mundanely, but does pick up towards the end.