2
LCM Rurinix
Reviewer's rating profile
2024-09-28
A collection of joke missions, and with 11 missions the joke gets pretty old pretty fast. I especially hated the mission where you have to chase and shoot at an invincible ship until the mission objective completes itself--most boring mission I have every played. This battle is good for some quick and easy RtF points, but it is not fun, not funny, and has no replay value.
5
CPT Jagged Fell III
Reviewer's rating profile
2024-04-10
Played on easy: Hilarious! I wasn't around back then but man I wish I was. I loved the humor in this battle.
5
CPT Nova Discordia
Reviewer's rating profile
2023-09-30
Bonkers series of missions, which I loved. Nice to see a mission designer who has such a kooky sense of humour, and doesn't take themselves at all seriously. Some of the missions were...bizarre, but kept my interest. A couple were even a little tricky. ALT-E is your friend here - it will make you die (you will understand when you start playing through the missions). Great stuff!
3
LCM Ludovicus Gallorum
Reviewer's rating profile
2023-09-04
Absolutely bonkers set of mission objectives. Comedy and in-jokes? Of course! These things are necessary from time to time. Even though these were fairly easy missions, dodging the TIE-A in Mission 9 took some doing and 10 was a puzzle to me, too before I figured out to just assist with the destruction of the CPOPOD myself. 6 and 7 required some careful and fast flying, too. Off-the-wall design but fun. I may come back to it someday.
4
CM Benji Tandor
Reviewer's rating profile
2023-06-21
Fun, silly nonsense.
My eighty-first battle in the TIE Corps.
5
VA Locke Setzer
Reviewer's rating profile
2023-05-24
As a former TCS (and former Tactical Office staff member under Frodo), how can I not love this battle? It is a wonderful bit of madness, full of laughs and technical tricks that often delight and provide unique challenges unlike anything else in the Compendium.
It also harkens back to a time when reviews didn't count for any kind of activity, and were very much in short supply! I believe Frodo made this primarily to get a reaction out of folks, knowing that most would either love it or hate it, but hopefully felt enough of either to submit a review. And so they have, for decades now... and hopefully decades more to come!
5
GN Master
Reviewer's rating profile
2023-05-24
All hail the mighty Frodo! I'd have his children if i could.
One of the most interesting battles I've ever played.
Do yourself a favor and fly it.
3
LC randyrumrnr
Reviewer's rating profile
2022-04-30
I'm going to admit that I have never met Frodo, and to be honest, I hope I never do. This guy appears to be an absolute madman. I can see what he was trying to do with this battle. But it was no less of a mind mess regardless of that. The missions were short, yet surprisingly well put together. Other pilots have submitted bug reports for a collision between Dreadnaughts, I somehow feel as tho this is by Frodo's design, so I will not be submitting a bug report.
0
LC andr3
Reviewer's rating profile
2022-02-25
11 "missions" that you can each finish in seconds or that you have to sit out. in most of them a primary goal is that you die. so keep your fingers close to the eject button. I know we are not supposed to insult the person who made the battle. can we insult the person who aproved it though? please?
5
LT Mosey
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-31
Why use many trick pony when one trick pony work just as good?
2
COL Highlander
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-28
Not sure if it was the game or my stick being out of calibration but I found the battles to be pretty buggy honestly but I did find the battles for the most part to be fun and frustrating all at the same time particularly the last couple given I could shoot Frodo and not deal any damage but all in all a fun mission
5
COL Gytheran
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-28
I flew this as part of Raise the Flag competition 2021. Of all the XvT battles I have flown this year, both 96 and 99 are easily my two favorite battles. There is only so much you can do in these missions, but the use of game mechanics in these two battles are completely out of left field from everything you have ever flown in XvT. I will likely be revisiting these battles to get ideas for my own battles in the future.
4
GN Silwar Naiilo
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-24
Where do I begin with this example of Frodo's insanity? You're instantly thrust into a meta-storyline as a TAC mission tester (or, rather, a series of them) trying to escape the craziness of this battle. It does some pretty neat tricks, and I'll admit I giggled every time I died and got a 'mission complete' voice line.
5
COL TheBlackxRanger
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-16
This is hands down the funniest set of missions i've ever played. Sometimes its good to play a battle where you dont have to try so hard and just enjoy the commentary. Very good use of the game building mechanics
4
MAJ Xye
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-16
Mixed feelings, but mostly good, confused ones. I'm afraid I'll be haunted if I don't leave a review, so: Other reviews have pretty well covered the non sequitur-ness nature of the battles. It's absurd and I'm all about that. The mechanics, such as they are, are fairly straight forward. Take the goals literally. In the the final mission is a straight dogfight, just make sure you stick close to your ISD because he's always in a T/A.
3
LC Solohan50
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-16
I played on Easy. I'm not actually sure how this battle got passed testing, honestly. This is closer to a very quick visual novel than it is an actually battle. That said, the storyline is funny and it has some unique mechanics. Dying as a requirement is something I've never seen before.
3
AD Phoenix Berkana
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-16
A somewhat strange battle, relatively easy to complete but at times very amusing. It’s very different than other battles out there, having your death as a primary mission goal is not common to say the least!
5
MAJ Wolve Excelsior Berkana
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-16
The most well crafted missions in the entire collection. This is pure genius. La creme de la creme. Frodo is in action again and this time he's out for vengeance. If you haven't already played it yet, this should be your initiation to the EH.
4
RA Genie
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-15
This is probably the epitome of Frodo's craziness and creativity with both its good and the bad. As I flew this one it gave me a sense of Groundhog Day with a dose of Happy Deathday (if you haven't seen these two movies you should, especially Groundhog Day). I love his creativity. Also, most of Frodo's battles carry the hallmark of entertaining in-flight messaging.
4
COL NiksaVel
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-12
Flew this on easy for the RTF 2021. I guess it was a weird battle when it was fresh, it's probably even weirder now. It has no sane plotline whatsoever and it's silly as hell. It was actually fun to fly it if you look at it as a demonstration of mission building skills.
5
MAJ Jaxx Nassin
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-12
There's a thin line between brilliance and insanity. Frodo proves again that it's impossible to tell which side of the line he falls on. I rated this mission an 11 out of 5, but had to deduct a star for every time I had to die >:( j/k I love battles that make me actually laugh out loud!
2
GN Stryker
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-09
What on Earth did I just fly? This mission is...wow. I don't know where to begin. Inside jokes that were funny 10 years ago (and a member of certain circles) have not aged well, leaving this mission more than a little baffling. 2/5 just because there are no bugs and it was an easy 44pts for RtF...
2
GN Stryker
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-10-09
What on Earth did I just fly? This mission is...wow. I don't know where to begin. Inside jokes that were funny 10 years ago (and a member of certain circles) have not aged well, leaving this mission more than a little baffling. 2/5 just because there are no bugs and it was an easy 44pts for RtF...
2
COL Phalk Sturm
Reviewer's rating profile
2021-07-24
Technical prowess. Shenanigans exploitation. Terrible experience. This battle is a jewel for those who are initiated in the inside jokes of Command Staff in those years. Otherwise, for the unknown layman, it's repetitive, tedious and what's more, felt like a waste of time. Sure, the occasional chuckle will appear, without a doubt. But felt like Alice's Mad Hatter designing a battle then falling asleep in a cloud of smoke while sharing a narghile with the Caterpillar. Easiest 10 FCHG points I've earnt, though. Crazy battle, look elsewhere if you are a square headed old man like myself, incapable of any humour.
2
GN Mark Schueler
Reviewer's rating profile
2015-06-17
As usual, a 'funny' battle that tries to hide unreasonably hard missions behind humour. Trying to inspect an ISD whilst being chased by missile armed A-Wings will never be funny.
5
LC Kadon Beir
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-03-10
By far the weirdest battle I've flown. But I think every mission here demonstrates the limits of creativity in XvT. From the strange objectives and triggers to having to die almost every mission, this one was a challenge yet fun.
3
GN Rancorous
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-03-09
I guess it's a simple case of you love it or you hate it and the 10 (11) mission mess is not my taste I'm afraid, if you don't like Frodo's "quirky humor" missions don't fly this. I'm afraid for me it is a bad joke that keeps getting worse. Some of the missions are fun and very challenging to complete but getting killed every other mission became real old, real quick. Didn't make me want to post a review either. Sorry Frodo, not one of your better battles in my opinion.
5
VA Zósite Kónstyte Styles
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-03-08
I hate you, Insane Halfling, do you hear me? HATE!! A 5 for you for being so damned crazy!! I enjoyed this battle so much that now I'd like to scourge all The Shire just for fun. xD I agree with LCM Holtz: it could have been nice to turn your starfighter to "pipe tobacco" in the last mission, and Palpatine knows how the hell can someone achieve those amazing highscores for missions 1 and 8! By the way, are you sure that your beloved ISD Intrepid can be disabled in Hard? I guess yes, given the classic Brucmack's annoying highscore there but hang me if I know how! Oh, well, this guy could even have been capable of disabling it himself... with a T/F!
5
HA Daniel Bonini
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-03-03
Completely nuts!!!! I like this kind of battle with crazy humor. There were things I didn't enjoy much, like some missions being too difficult for a shieldless craft, and the fact that there were too many missions that looked alike...still, I give it a 5 for the humor!
4
LCM Oskar Holtz
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-03-03
After playing this I don't know if I dare not to post a review! A crazy mission and pretty funny too. Surviving in a Tie when needed can be quite challenging. The only bad thing about this battle is in the last mission where it would have been good to be able to take revenge on the hobbit :D
4
LT Trent Devson
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-02-22
This battle was.... different. Very unique and despite te humorous nature of the battle (wich I generally don't care for) it was good. I did really enjoy this one.
4
CM Sabbath
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-02-21
Sooo many missions, but, at least they were each quite simple. I really iked the introduction of the omnipotence of Frodo into his battles.
5
GN Kaisin Mirtez
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-02-21
Gonna kill the hobbit for this one. No really was alot of fun to fly and had some very intersting plts to it, YOU MUST DIE. missions where I have to die, this one was new to me. Never knew bag end was so big, thought it was just under a tree. Loved this one and hope theres more like. Nice Job Frodo
3
COL Den Darkhill
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-02-20
Well 10 Mission Mess is a good name. A very unique idea for a battle but the missions kind of drag on. Even at 11 missions its quick to get through.
4
GN Abel Malik
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-02-14
If nothing else the battles unique.. who else would kill so many poor hapless beta testers (tcs's)?;p. Also, I believe the pilot (you) dieing as a primary mission objective is a original idea- that and in the one missions COL Morgan did more work there than in 96' as a Prae! Fo' shizzle! ;p.
5
COL Flint Darkstar
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-02-11
Frodo all the way. If there were no name attached to this thing, who else do you think would have created it? Yes, the missions are all dumb, but that's not the point. It is probably one of the most original and well-carried out ideas for a plotline in this whole database. Definitely worth flying once for the quickest 11 FCHG points ever, and worth flying again to catch all the goofball humor mixed into the battle. ... PAR!
3
COL Zystem Fryar
Reviewer's rating profile
2007-02-11
One of the most ANNOYING battles ever - FRODO you should have your Brain checked... - this is Annoying and mostly boring :( -- ABSOLUTELY awful battle to use in a comp.
5
LT Bryan
Reviewer's rating profile
2006-05-10
Funny battle Frodo. Long enough to help your FCHG out, funny enough to let you have a good time, and at the same time frustrating because Frodo gets to kill you. :P Another one of Frodo's great battles!
3
LC Big Poppa K
Reviewer's rating profile
2005-11-30
It's like one of those jokes that isn't funny at first, but then becomes funny by it's own irony, or something like that.
5
LC Gen Es'mith
Reviewer's rating profile
2005-11-03
I loved it. I beta tested it, I flew it and I loved it. Very original idea. Nice work Fro!
3
CM TK-9780
Reviewer's rating profile
2005-04-09
Best ever made.......No, brilliant and imaginative........Yes. Best played whilst consuming large quintiles of Alcohol based beverages. Sorry and with a fish stuck in your ear.
5
LCM Topace31
Reviewer's rating profile
2005-02-09
PAR!!!:9
4
COL Brucmack
Reviewer's rating profile
2005-02-06
Amusing, but the missions themselves didn't have much action in them. 69 got a bit of action though, which was fun. All in all, I'd say the battle's a birdie, but not quite eagle material.
5
COL Nightmare
Reviewer's rating profile
2005-01-28
Great battle, Originaly it was supposed to be the 20 mission mess with 22 missions but I couldn't make an opt and ender didn't want to make one for us so it ended up being this... Yay!
5
MAJ Fox Malloy
Reviewer's rating profile
2005-01-24
Well made, and rather funny. I would have given it a four, but that bit of innuendo caused me to give it a 5. Excellent work on this one, Frodo. Oh, dear me. Almost forgot: PAR!!!
5
FA Marcin Szydlowski
Reviewer's rating profile
2005-01-15
Buehehehehhee!!! uahahahahahah! Mwuahahahahah! Hihihihih! The most funny battle I've ever flown :P
5
CM Kakihara
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-08-27
Aah... Grand Battle this is. These are true missions, for true pilots!
5
COL BubbaX
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-08-20
I was forced to fly this...and it had one mission more than it should have had. It was fun, though. Monkey poo to you, Frooodoooo.
4
MAJ Tek Selkirk
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-08-12
Good overall, but the missions where you just fly around are somewhat annoying.
5
CPT Jan Pieter
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-08-04
Great Battle Loved the fact that you had to die to win made things more fun and it went on forever
5
COL Malidir
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-07-27
Great stuff...dying every mission is frustrating, but not too different from lots of other stuff I fly on hard :P
5
COL Rau Aznable
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-07-25
Probably the best battle ever made! When I saw the number of missions I thought "Oh, this will take me almost a week to finish", but it took me only an hour, because I couldn't stop playing! And study this mission, all you mission creators! There's a lot of stuff here that can be used on more serious stuff. PAR!
5
AD Gidda
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-07-13
Confusing and irritating, just as its creator =)
5
COL TK-7764
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-07-09
Must... review... battle. Don't forget Alt+E (eject).
5
CM Shinobi
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-07-08
Some mysterious force forced me to PAR :P Well very good battle kinda funny :P DUnno if i enjoyed getting killed on every missioon tho :P
4
LC Brin Chaser
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-07-06
Finally! A feasible action plan to utilise TAC reservists! j/k :P More battles like this, please :) It was tightly designed, easy to play through and FUN. There were just one or two minor phrasing errors, which keeps this from being a five. Almost Frodo. Almost :)
5
COL Justin
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-06-30
10 erm I mean 11 missions of pure greatness :P It was actually fun to play and had some... uniquely interesting aspects to it :P
5
HA Frodo March
Reviewer's rating profile
2004-06-21
The Most daring, amazing and Awesome battle of all time has finally been released at a mission compendium near you! These 11 missions will simply strike you as stupid, idiotic...maybe even DUMB! And you'll have a blast giving 35 minutes of your time to get 11 FCHG points!! ;)
2021-02-22
Previous report on Mission #9 by GN Polo is actually for Mission #6.
There is a problem with Mission #9 though: the briefing and animation both state the container is set to Invincible and must be destroyed by repeatedly crashing into it. The container is not set to Invincible.
2013-09-09
Mission 6: DREAD group Gangsta fly "through" each other due to bad waypoint pathing. This can cause them to be destroyed before the ISD Intrepid is disabled.
2010-05-11
Mission 9: DREAD Gangsta collide with each other in pairs above and below the Intrepid.
Battle Total: | 214,590 | COL Brucmack | |
---|---|---|---|
Mission 1: | 14,600 | COL Brucmack | 2005-02-05 |
Mission 2: | 42,600 | HA Daniel Bonini | |
Mission 3: | 11,200 | COL TK-7764 | |
Mission 4: | 9,800 | CPT Von Predator | |
Mission 5: | 12,960 | COL TK-7764 | |
Mission 6: | 49,950 | COL Brucmack | |
Mission 7: | 39,200 | COL Brucmack | |
Mission 8: | 21,280 | COL Brucmack | |
Mission 9: | 18,000 | COL Brucmack | |
Mission 10: | 11,600 | COL Brucmack | |
Mission 11: | 9,800 | CPT Von Predator |
(of available records)
1 | 214,590 | COL Brucmack | 2005-02-05 |
2 | 150,920 | MAJ Tuba | 2011-11-12 |
3 | 145,340 | COL Rau Aznable | 2004-07-25 |
4 | 143,283 | COL TheBlackxRanger | 2023-06-04 |
5 | 141,485 | AD Gidda | 2004-07-15 |
6 | 128,440 | CM LPhoenix | 2024-09-01 |
7 | 123,530 | FA Pickled Yoda | 2023-06-03 |
8 | 123,310 | COL TK-7764 | 2004-07-12 |
9 | 122,356 | LC Solohan50 | 2023-06-04 |
10 | 117,540 | CM Patrick Blastfire | 2004-08-22 |
This battle has been flown by 137 pilots a total of 191 times.
GN Abel Malik - 2004-07-21
HA Anahorn Dempsey - 4 times, last on 2021-02-22
LC andr3 - 2022-02-25
COL Benjamin Jahou Morgan - 2005-02-28
CM Benji Tandor - 2023-06-21
LC Brin Chaser - 2004-07-07
COL Brucmack - 2005-02-05
COL BubbaX - 2004-08-20
LC Choosh - 2004-10-09
RA Colo Delste - 2 times, last on 2023-06-24
FA Conker Blackwood - 2009-11-17
GN Coranel Both - 2 times, last on 2023-09-10
COL CrimsonFury - 2004-08-06
LC Daisuke Airyu - 2004-07-29
CM Daniel Russell - 2005-06-13
LCM Das Oberon - 2023-09-06
GN Dax Corrin - 2004-07-05
GN Dunta Polo - 3 times, last on 2013-09-08
LT Eifel - 2005-06-11
CM El Guapo - 2004-07-27
GN Elwood the Brave - 2 times, last on 2022-10-02
COL Flint Darkstar - 2005-06-06
MAJ Fox Malloy - 2005-01-24
RA fr0Zen - 2 times, last on 2023-09-10
HA Frodo March - 2 times, last on 2014-06-14
RA Genie - 3 times, last on 2023-09-25
LCM Gian Webb - 2023-09-24
AD Gidda - 2004-07-15
COL Gyssler - 2012-08-07
COL Gytheran - 4 times, last on 2024-05-01
AD Hav Antiel - 2020-05-24
MAJ Hermann - 2 times, last on 2021-10-12
COL Highlander - 2 times, last on 2024-05-09
CPT Jagged Fell III - 3 times, last on 2024-09-01
MAJ Jaxx Nassin - 2021-10-12
COL Justin - 2004-07-05
CM Kakihara - 2004-08-27
LT Kate Flyer - 2005-04-30
MAJ Kazraran - 2021-03-16
MAJ KEBLAOMEGA - 3 times, last on 2024-09-03
LC Kenath Zoron - 2009-05-16
LT Konig - 2021-10-31
VA Locke Setzer - 2 times, last on 2024-09-02
CM LPhoenix - 2 times, last on 2024-09-01
LCM Ludovicus Gallorum - 2023-09-04
COL Malidir - 2 times, last on 2009-02-08
FA Marcin Szydlowski - 2005-01-15
GN Mark Schueler - 2015-06-17
GN Master - 3 times, last on 2024-09-29
CM Michael K Starburst - 2004-12-09
CM Milo Antu - 2021-10-20
COL Moagim Daar - 2005-04-28
LT Mosey - 2021-10-31
COL Nightmare - 2005-01-16
COL NiksaVel - 2021-10-12
CPT Nova Discordia - 2023-09-30
RA Nutrientman - 2005-01-30
CM Patrick Blastfire - 2004-08-22
HA Pete Mitchell - 2017-10-15
COL Phalk Sturm - 2 times, last on 2021-10-30
AD Phoenix Berkana - 2 times, last on 2022-10-20
FA Pickled Yoda - 7 times, last on 2024-05-25
LC randyrumrnr - 2022-04-30
COL Rau Aznable - 2004-07-25
LCM Rez Chaser - 2004-07-06
LCM Rosh Nyine - 2 times, last on 2024-09-08
LCM Rurinix - 2024-09-28
CPT S 4patas - 2005-05-09
LC Savageaz - 2004-07-25
CM scottrick - 2024-09-17
CM Shinobi - 2004-07-16
GN Silwar Naiilo - 2021-10-15
LC Solohan50 - 4 times, last on 2024-05-02
LC Spade - 2004-07-27
GN Stryker - 2021-10-09
CPT Syntroth - 2022-10-02
LC Taygetta - 2021-10-18
MAJ Tek Selkirk - 2004-08-12
COL TheBlackxRanger - 3 times, last on 2023-09-01
COL TK-7764 - 2004-07-12
CM TK-9780 - 2005-04-11
LCM Topace31 - 2005-02-08
GN Triji Boliv - 2022-05-16
MAJ Tuba - 2011-11-12
CPT Tvan'Oris - 2005-02-14
LC Vapen Van’an - 2023-06-29
CPT Von Predator - 2004-07-05
LT Wenton Chan - 2004-07-09
COL Westric Davalorn - 3 times, last on 2024-05-02
CPT Wildfire - 2021-10-18
CPT Witchblade - 2021-10-16
MAJ Wolve Excelsior Berkana - 13 times, last on 2024-09-08
MAJ Xye - 2021-10-16
MAJ Zhaim Jifarr - 2005-02-14
COL Zystem Fryar - 2004-07-05
TITLE: The 10 Mission Mess MISSIONS: 11 (No, Really 11) MEDAL: The crumpled piece of paper of doom GAME PLATFORM: X-Wing vs TIE Fighter Created by: COM/VA Frodo March/ISD Intrepid Required patches ---------------- none Installation instructions -------------------------- 1] Double click the .EHM file, the EH Battle Launcher will install the battle 2] Check the Misc folder in your XvT one for additional material like patches, sounds etc. 3] Press the X-wing vs TIE Fighter button on the EHBL to start the game 4] Create a new pilot and fly the Imperial training missions Hardware used: Pentium 133Mhz, 5 year old Microsoft Sidewinder Joystick, XvTED THIS LEVEL IS NOT MADE, DISTRIBUTED, OR SUPPORTED BY LUCASARTS ENTERTAINMENT COMPANY. ELEMENTS TM & © LUCASARTS ENTERTAINMENT COMPANY. But it is distributed, and supported by Frothy© And Hobbits everywhere!!! :))